Skip to content
A considered view of the world.
TravelGuys

The dangers of a loyalty program that gives status without flying

Strange as it may seem, there are loyalty programs that allow you to obtain a status without actually being a customer, or at least not a loyal or frequent one. This may be tempting for the customer, but it’s a double-edged sword for both the airline and the customer.

Aeroplan launches Everyday Status

Some time ago, Aeroplan, Air Canada’s frequent flyer program, joined the club of the very few frequent flyer programs that allow customers to obtain status without flying.

With its Everyday Status, the program offers its members the chance to earn points on everyday purchases paid for with a co-branded credit card linked to the program. These points can be used to reach the 25K status, the lowest in the program.

“Achieve Aeroplan Elite status before you even take off. The points you accumulate every day – through Aeroplan credit card purchases, reservations on flights operated by Air Canada and its partner carriers, and spending with our travel and retail partners – will help you move one step closer to status.

Earn 100,000 points in one calendar year through qualifying transactions, and you’ll enjoy Aeroplan 25K status the following year.”

An interesting offer for the customer…though

For someone who doesn’t travel much, this is a pretty attractive offer. Even though the 25K status is the lowest in the program, it gives access to a number of interesting benefits, such as priority check-in and boarding, and an additional baggage allowance. It’s tempting to be able to reach this status with your everyday expenses, and take advantage of it on vacation.

However, I see several limits to this concept.

The first is that only 25K status is attainable.

The second is that, based on the way it’s explained on the Air Canada website, it’s a parallel way of earning status and not a boost to the “normal” program. Let me explain.

One might have thought that the points earned through spending would be added to those earned by flying or spending money at Air Canada to help reach the 25K faster, but this is clearly not the case.

So if a person earns 50,000 points in spending, that doesn’t allow them to spend only $1,500 at Air Canada and fly only 12,500 miles or 13 segments. It’s one or the other.

A profitable offer for Air Canada

By encouraging Aeroplan members to use a co-branded credit card, Air Canada is making a very good financial deal.

As we’ve already explained, the co-branded credit card business is very profitable: these expenses earn points, these points are bought by the financial organization from Aeroplan, and in the end, it pays off handsomely. Some even use their loyalty programs as collateral for bank financing, as it’s a more solid and profitable business than passenger transport.

Beware of program devaluation

But by promoting the attainment of status and multiplying the number of members who have access to it, there is a risk that this status will eventually be devalued.

When there are too many people at boarding or priority check-in, it is safe to predict that one of these benefits will disappear from the 25K.

Don’t disappoint the real passengers

Last but not least, this kind of practice is frowned upon by “real” passengers, those who earn their status by flying. They don’t understand that the priority queues are clogged with people who only fly once or twice a year, that the program risks being devalued because of these people, and that in the end, people less loyal than them will have the same recognition from the airline.

The Flying Blue precedent

If you remember, the same debate took place over Flying Blue, Air France and KLM’s loyalty program, when it was last overhauled.

Like today, it enabled American Express Air France cardholders to earn miles with their daily spending, but at the time, these miles were status-qualifying. Unlike Aeroplan, these miles were added to those earned by flying, and were a real booster that gave access to all program statuses, not just the lowest. After the redesign, “Amex miles” were no longer qualifying award miles: naturally, those who made the most use of this scheme were the big losers in the Flying Blue redesign.

It’s exactly for the reasons given above, and explained in the article linked just above, that we were in favor of this redesign, but this is an opportunity for us to re-explain the basics of how a loyalty program works in a healthy way.

What is a healthy loyalty program?

There are in fact two components to a loyalty program: statuses, which entitle you to benefits, and points or miles, which enable you to buy “free” tickets (not so free, they’re paid for before….).

For us, status should reflect loyalty, and therefore depend solely on the number of flights, distance flown and travel class.

Award miles, which can be used to purchase flights, are equivalent to money and must therefore be backed by an income.

It is therefore clear to us that the points earned for spending with a co-branded credit card must not be used in any way to grant status.

Bottom line

There are several reasons why we do not support Aeroplan’s system.

The first, as we’ve just explained, is that it contravenes what we consider to be the sound operation of a loyalty program. The risk of devaluation in the long term is quite obvious, and “real” Air Canada customers may not take kindly to being treated in the same way as certain occasional customers.

The second is that as long as Aeroplan is going in this direction, it’s not going far enough. It might as well adopt the same system as the old Flying Blue and make spending with a credit card a boost to achieving any status.

Image : loyalty programs by Andrey_Popov via Shutterstock

Bertrand Duperrin
Bertrand Duperrinhttp://www.duperrin.com
Compulsive traveler, present in the French #avgeek community since the late 2000s and passionate about (long) travel since his youth, Bertrand Duperrin co-founded Travel Guys with Olivier Delestre in March 2015.
1,324FansLike
954FollowersFollow
1,272FollowersFollow
370SubscribersSubscribe

Trending posts

Recent posts

Bacchanal: a welcome renovation, but booking needs to be clearer

Caesars Palace will renovate its flagship buffet in 2027. We welcome the decision. But guests booking today should already be able to find the price of their dinner more easily and understand what their chosen time guarantees.

Hyatt and Delta: a partnership with uneven benefits

The Hyatt–Delta partnership is now up and running. Medallion members gain a new hotel benefit. For Hyatt loyalists, Delta’s ticket restrictions and the choice of airline program make the deal less appealing, especially for those who use Flying Blue.

Expedia cyberattack: the risk goes beyond payment details

Expedia has confirmed an intrusion through a vendor, but its scope remains unclear. Even without card numbers, booking details can make a scam convincing. Our view on protecting travel accounts.

FAA outage: the cost of a fragile air traffic control system

US airlines spent the weekend rebuilding their schedules after the November 13 outage. We look at which flights they prioritized, the rebooking options and the refund rights available to passengers.