Skip to content
A considered view of the world.
TravelGuys

FAA outage: the cost of a fragile air traffic control system

On Friday evening, the FAA lifted the nationwide ground stop in the United States. For travelers, the weekend had already been badly disrupted. Flights had been canceled and connections missed. Aircraft and crews still needed to get to the right airports. Permission to take off again could not make up for hours of disruption.

As of 9:35 p.m. Eastern on Sunday, The Points Guy counted 18,126 cancellations from Friday through Sunday, using FlightAware data. That figure includes cancellations for all reasons, not just the FAA outage. It still gives a sense of the weekend travelers experienced at US airports.

On Sunday evening, American forecast a largely normal schedule for Monday. Welcome news, but little comfort for a passenger stranded all weekend. That is part of the problem with US aviation: an outage lasting a few hours can cost passengers several days.

Cover photograph. Aircraft parked at Chicago O’Hare on October 29, 2018. Archive photograph. Photo: Raysonho @ Open Grid Scheduler / Scalable Grid Engine / Wikimedia Commons, CC0 1.0. Resized.

The FAA was right to stop departures

According to the Federal Aviation Administration, which oversees US air traffic control, the problem began on Friday, November 13, at about 3:30 p.m. Eastern. Traffic resumed at 8:15 p.m. The agency reported instability at 17 of its 22 en route control centers and several approach control facilities. Some radio frequencies and radar feeds remained available; according to the FAA, aircraft already in the air were able to land safely.

A departure information screen at Chicago O’Hare, photographed on March 15, 2017.
A departure screen at Chicago O’Hare on March 15, 2017. Archive photograph. Photo: Redolta / Wikimedia Commons, CC0 1.0. Resized.

Under those conditions, stopping departures was the right decision. Aircraft should not keep taking off to protect a schedule when air traffic control cannot work normally. The problem was the scale of the outage, rather than the controllers’ caution.

On Saturday, Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy described routine work replacing copper telecommunications links with fiber. Faulty equipment and an installation error were among the possibilities being examined. The investigation continues, so we do not yet know what caused the incident.

The investigation needs to explain how the problem spread and why departures had to be halted so widely. Controllers handled the emergency. It is now up to the FAA to show how it can prevent a repeat.

Modernization means more than buying equipment

US air traffic control needs to replace its aging infrastructure. No one benefits from keeping equipment that has become difficult to maintain. The work must be organized so that the rest of the network can keep running.

The planning problem was known before Friday. In a report published on September 14, the Government Accountability Office found no reliable estimate of the program’s total lifecycle cost and no master schedule coordinating the work. The watchdog identified 11,389 separate project schedules.

The Newark Liberty control tower under a blue sky, photographed on September 28, 2013.
The Newark Liberty control tower on September 28, 2013. Archive photograph. Photo: Djflem / Wikimedia Commons, CC0 1.0. Resized.

That report does not identify the cause of the outage. It shows that the FAA was already struggling to explain how its entire modernization program fit together. With so much work to complete, knowing who is doing it, where and in what order is more than an administrative detail. That coordination is essential if equipment is to be replaced while aircraft keep flying.

American prioritized flights that would help the recovery

After several hours without departures, airlines cannot simply call passengers back to the gate. Some airports no longer have the aircraft they need. Crews are out of position for the next day’s flights. And customers need seats on flights already booked by other travelers.

American explained its decision in its Friday evening statement: prioritize flights to non-hub cities and international services to reposition aircraft and crews. At 11 p.m. Central on Sunday, the airline forecast a largely normal schedule for Monday.

That choice is defensible. An aircraft stuck at a hub may be needed in another city the next day, and its absence can disrupt several subsequent flights. Getting it moving may therefore be more useful than always prioritizing the largest airports. It also explains why the first flight to depart may not be carrying the passengers who have waited longest.

A United Airlines Boeing 737-900ER in flight near Fort Lauderdale on October 31, 2021.
A United Airlines Boeing 737-900ER near Fort Lauderdale on October 31, 2021. Archive photograph. Photo: CC0 airplane FLL airport / Wikimedia Commons, CC0 1.0. Resized.

We will not fault an airline for trying to get its operation back on track. Sometimes an early cancellation is better than delaying a flight all evening when it is no longer realistic to operate it. But that does not resolve matters for the people whose flight was canceled. Good results for the next day’s departures do not tell us how many customers are still waiting for a seat.

The Port of Seattle made the point on Saturday: the airport was open and the national ground stop had been lifted, but delays persisted. Passengers therefore needed to check their own flight with the airline before heading to the airport. An announcement that traffic has resumed does not mean every passenger can continue their journey.

Postponing a trip: American and Delta offer different options

Airlines have relaxed their ticket rules so some customers can travel later. That helps people able to postpone their trips and may free seats for passengers who need to get home. But the dates and conditions vary by airline.

American’s advisory, which we checked on November 16, covers the airports it lists and tickets purchased by November 12 for travel originally scheduled for November 13–18. Changes must be booked by November 18, for travel between November 13 and 21, without changing the origin or destination city. Travelers must keep the same cabin or pay the difference. Basic Economy tickets are eligible too.

Travelers at the check-in counters in Washington Dulles’ main terminal on March 24, 2022.
The check-in area in Washington Dulles’ main terminal on March 24, 2022. Archive photograph. Photo: Famartin / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0. Resized.

Delta’s notice covers travel from November 13 through 16 across its network, for tickets issued by November 15. Both the change and the new departure must take place by November 23. Delta waives the fare difference when the notice’s conditions are met, including staying in the cabin originally booked. Changing the origin or destination city may cost more.

Change fees and the price of the replacement flight are different things. An airline can waive the fee and still charge a fare difference. Before accepting a rebooking, customers need to check the total cost and when they will actually arrive. An earlier departure is no help if the proposed connection delays arrival by another day.

Buying another ticket yourself may seem quicker than waiting for the airline to rebook you. Be aware of the risks of connections on separate tickets. If the first flight is delayed, the second airline is not necessarily required to rebook you at no charge. You also need to check with the original airline what happens to the ticket you no longer plan to use.

The Indianapolis airport control tower, viewed from the parking garage on November 6, 2009.
The Indianapolis control tower viewed from the parking garage on November 6, 2009. Archive photograph. Photo: Aiko, Thomas & Juliette+Isaac / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0. Resized.

Refunds, hotels and compensation are three separate issues

An FAA outage does not remove the refund rights provided by US rules. The Department of Transportation makes clear that after a cancellation, regardless of its cause, passengers can get their money back if they decline the transportation offered and do not accept a credit. Certain significant changes or delays also qualify. This can include an arrival delay of three hours or more on a domestic itinerary or six hours or more on an international one.

A refund returns the fare for the transportation the passenger chooses not to take. It is not paid in addition to a journey completed on the delayed or replacement flight. Nor does it guarantee another ticket at the same price. If a trip has lost its purpose, getting the money back may be enough. For someone trying to get home from abroad, that does not in itself solve the problem.

Hotel nights and meals come under different rules. The DOT’s dashboard of airline commitments concerns disruptions within the airlines’ control. Those commitments do not amount to a blanket promise to pay for hotels and meals after a nationwide air traffic control outage. The cause of the particular cancellation still needs to be examined: several days after the incident, merely citing the FAA does not settle every case.

Vehicles and travelers outside the terminals at Atlanta airport on February 23, 2024.
Road access to Atlanta’s terminals on February 23, 2024. Archive photograph. Photo: Chris Rycroft / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0. Resized.

For a flight departing the European Union, EU rules apply regardless of the airline. For a flight from the United States to the EU, they apply if it is operated by an EU airline. An air traffic management decision can exempt an airline from fixed compensation when the relevant conditions are met; it does not remove applicable obligations to provide care. A ticket refund, reimbursement of expenses and fixed compensation are therefore not the same thing.

The weekend passengers lost

The airlines did not cause the outage. Nor can they keep enough aircraft and crews in reserve to absorb a nationwide halt without delays. Explaining why a flight was canceled and helping the customer reach their destination are different tasks. Once departures resume, airlines need to be judged on that second job.

The FAA needs to explain how a technical incident could disrupt flights for an entire weekend. The investigation will establish what happened and what needs correcting. For passengers, the consequences are already clear: canceled departures, missed connections and lost time. Asking passengers to be patient during an outage is reasonable. Afterward, they deserve more than a promise to do better next time.

Olivier Delestre-Levai
Olivier Delestre-Levai
Olivier has been into airline blogging since 2010. First a major contributor to the FlyerTalk forum, he created the FlyerPlan website in July 2012, and writes articles with a major echo among airline specialists. He now co-runs the TravelGuys blog with Bertrand, focusing on travel experience and loyalty programs.
1,324FansLike
954FollowersFollow
1,272FollowersFollow
370SubscribersSubscribe

Trending posts

Recent posts

Bacchanal: a welcome renovation, but booking needs to be clearer

Caesars Palace will renovate its flagship buffet in 2027. We welcome the decision. But guests booking today should already be able to find the price of their dinner more easily and understand what their chosen time guarantees.

Hyatt and Delta: a partnership with uneven benefits

The Hyatt–Delta partnership is now up and running. Medallion members gain a new hotel benefit. For Hyatt loyalists, Delta’s ticket restrictions and the choice of airline program make the deal less appealing, especially for those who use Flying Blue.

Expedia cyberattack: the risk goes beyond payment details

Expedia has confirmed an intrusion through a vendor, but its scope remains unclear. Even without card numbers, booking details can make a scam convincing. Our view on protecting travel accounts.

FAA outage: the cost of a fragile air traffic control system

US airlines spent the weekend rebuilding their schedules after the November 13 outage. We look at which flights they prioritized, the rebooking options and the refund rights available to passengers.