Skip to content
A considered view of the world.
TravelGuys

Restaurants: show the real price and spare us the surcharges

The debate revived in Chicago on October 28 raises a straightforward question: why add fees to the bill instead of showing the real price of a meal? Restaurants have costs to cover. Customers should be able to find out what they will pay before ordering, without having to negotiate when the check arrives.

In Chicago, restaurant surcharges are proving hard to shake

An Axios report published on October 28, 2026 has put Chicago’s restaurant surcharges back in the news. They are less glamorous than a new Michelin star or an opening by a famous chef. Yet they matter to anyone looking for a restaurant while traveling: how much will the meal actually cost? Even excellent cooking can leave a bad taste when it takes work to make sense of the check. A disappointing way to end what should have been an enjoyable evening.

The restaurants’ own terms make the issue clear. Boka Restaurant Group announces a 4% surcharge to offset what it describes as rising costs without raising menu prices. Customers can ask to have it removed. At Beatrix, Lettuce Entertain You lists a 3.5% surcharge, also removable on request. We checked these pages on October 29. They set out the terms displayed on that date but do not say when the surcharges were introduced.

Dining room and counter at Pacific Standard Time in Chicago, photographed in 2019
Historical illustration: Pacific Standard Time, Chicago, 2019 — Bex Walton, via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0. Image resized. This is an illustration, not evidence of the restaurant’s surcharge policy.

To be clear, we are examining these restaurants’ published terms and what they mean for customers. This is not a restaurant review. We are not going to invent a conversation with a server or an argument over the bill. We can still criticize a documented pricing policy. Equally, those policies do not establish that every restaurant in Chicago follows the same rules.

Our view is straightforward: rising costs can justify a more expensive meal, but not a price that is harder to understand. Automatically adding a percentage and then removing it for those who object makes the bill depend on how closely customers pay attention and how comfortable they are speaking up. That is an odd approach to hospitality. We go to a restaurant to choose a meal, not to negotiate how each of the business’s expenses will be covered.

For visitors from abroad, the surcharge adds another rule to an already unfamiliar set of customs: taxes, tipping and reservation conditions, sometimes in a language they do not speak well. Having to spot an operating-cost fee adds nothing to the meal. It simply makes choosing a restaurant and paying more complicated. The time to explain the price is when customers compare restaurants or read the menu. Once they have ordered, some of that information has already come too late.

Of course we are not asking restaurants to operate at a loss. We are asking them to display the prices they need to run their businesses. A more expensive dish, priced openly, lets customers make an informed choice. An apparently cheaper dish with automatic fees requires them to work out the price themselves. Even when only a few dollars are involved, the difference matters: one approach gives customers a price; the other asks them to reconstruct it.

A 4% surcharge is still a 4% increase

Take a hypothetical example, leaving out tax and tips so we can focus on the surcharge. Two people order $100 worth of food and drinks. Add a 4% fee and they pay $104. Whether the extra four dollars are built into the dishes or added at the bottom of the check, they come out of the same pocket. Keeping $100 on the menu does not change the result: the meal now costs four dollars more.

From the customer’s perspective, the claim that these fees avoid raising menu prices does not stand up to much scrutiny. The printed figures beside the dishes may indeed remain unchanged. The cost of the meal still rises. That is the distinction that matters: preserving the displayed prices is not the same as protecting the diner’s budget. Ultimately, customers care about the amount charged to their card, not how the restaurant has chosen to present it.

Some restaurant owners want to explain their pressures by breaking down their costs. Fine: nothing stops them doing so after stating the total price. Consider another example. A $26 dish, with an explanation that part of the price covers staffing costs, is presented very differently from a $25 dish with a surcharge customers must calculate. A business can explain its costs and still tell diners the full price up front.

Otherwise, comparisons become needlessly difficult. Imagine two comparable dishes priced at $25 and $26. A 4% surcharge on the first brings both to $26, before any other applicable amounts. The lower figure did not identify the cheaper meal; it concealed part of the price. When traveling, we have better things to do than repeat those calculations for every menu just to find out whether two restaurants actually charge the same amount.

Dining room and bar at Two Lights in Chicago, 2019
Historical illustration: Two Lights, Chicago, 2019 — Bex Walton, via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0. Image resized. This is an illustration, not evidence of the restaurant’s surcharge policy.

None of this establishes that the fees are illegal. Requirements vary by location, and we are not deciding that question here. Our concern is clarity for customers. A disclosure can be present yet easy to miss; a surcharge can be calculable yet make comparisons difficult. Complying with the rules is essential. A restaurant that wants to earn trust should also make its prices obvious, without expecting every diner to search for the small print.

We should not automatically assume bad intentions either. A small team may want to explain a price increase without being able to replace its menus and other materials immediately. That can make sense as a temporary arrangement. It is much less convincing as a permanent habit. At some point, the restaurant’s ordinary expenses need to be reflected in its ordinary prices. Customers should not have to adapt indefinitely to a system simply because the business finds it easier to manage.

Restaurants face real pressures. Customers have budgets too.

The economic backdrop should not be dismissed. In its October 14, 2026 update, the National Restaurant Association reported that U.S. menu prices rose 3.5% year over year in September. That national figure, published by a trade organization, says nothing about the profitability of an individual restaurant. It cannot tell us its margins, which expenses it could absorb or what increase it would need to pass on to diners.

The Illinois Restaurant Association’s March survey of 204 Chicago full-service restaurants offers a view of local pressures: 29% of respondents said they had not been profitable over the preceding twelve months. These are operators’ responses to their own association, with the sampling limitations that entails. The findings point to genuine concern within the industry. They do not establish why any particular restaurant is losing money, or identify one cause behind every business’s difficulties.

Acknowledging those pressures does not mean accepting every explanation without question. Ingredients, wages, rent and energy all affect the accounts, but their impact varies with the location, contracts and type of restaurant. A national figure cannot prove that a particular fee is indispensable at a particular establishment. We should be consistent in both directions: customers’ irritation, however understandable, does not prove that the owner can absorb every cost without raising prices either.

A more useful discussion would examine how the restaurant operates. Depending on the circumstances, a shorter menu, revised opening hours, a fixed-price offering or reduced waste might help. None is a magic solution: each has drawbacks, and some simply will not suit a particular business. But they remind us that other questions can be asked. Presenting the surcharge as the only alternative to closing down narrows the choices available to an operator rather too quickly.

Above all, a restaurant owner’s difficulties do not make the customer’s disappear. A family on vacation, someone paying out of pocket or an employee with an expense limit also has a budget to manage. Saying that a fee is small does not explain why it is charged separately. People can afford those few dollars and still find the method irritating. The objection concerns how the price is presented as much as the amount being asked for.

We are happy to defend the price of a job well done. Proper staffing, good ingredients and attentive service cost money; restaurants should be able to say so and charge accordingly. That is more honest, and probably more commercially demanding, than displaying an attractive figure and topping it up on the check. It also gives the team’s work the respect it deserves. Charging properly for a meal should not require an unwelcome surprise at the end of it.

“We can take it off”: you still have to ask

Being able to request removal is better than having no choice. Restaurants deserve credit for that distinction: a charge described as removable is not quite the same as one imposed without recourse. But the option does not solve the underlying problem. Customers must notice the line, understand that they can refuse it and then speak up. The restaurant decided to add it, yet the customer is left to take the steps needed to undo that decision.

Booths and tables at Bridgeport Family Restaurant in Chicago, 2016
Historical illustration: Bridgeport Family Restaurant, 2016 — David Wilson, via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0. Image resized. This is an illustration, not evidence of the restaurant’s surcharge policy.

And what an awkward time to do it. After a meal, people want to pay, say thank you and leave. Instead, they have to scrutinize the check, identify the fee and ask their server to remove it. That sounds simple when written down. In practice, they may be treating friends, hosting a business client or struggling with the language. That is not necessarily when they want to start a discussion about a few dollars in front of everyone at the table.

This discomfort is not something we have invented to exaggerate the issue. A November 20, 2024 report by ABC7 Chicago already described customers’ reluctance to ask and criticism from consumer groups. We cite the older report to show that the problem is not new. It does not establish a new rule in 2026, nor are we assuming that the legal proceedings mentioned at the time remain at the same stage today.

The outcome is also rather strange: for the same order, someone who knows the rules and is comfortable asking can pay less than someone who noticed nothing or wants to avoid a discussion. No hidden motive needs to be assumed; that follows from how the removal option works. Two tables can order exactly the same food and drinks yet leave with different bills. The meal has nothing to do with the difference. It depends on the customer’s willingness to challenge a charge.

A genuine optional extra should be clear before ordering and easy to decline. A wine pairing, an additional course or a particular service can work perfectly well that way, provided the choice and price are explicit. Adding a fee by default and waiting for someone to request its removal is another matter. It means charging customers unless they say something. We struggle to see that as a good way to make diners feel welcome.

The answer is not to make servers recite another explanation when it is time to pay. It is to remove the need for that conversation. A full price known before ordering spares everyone the discussion: customers do not have to object, and staff do not have to defend a policy they may not have chosen. Simplifying the bill also keeps employees from being left on the front line to deal with the consequences of a commercial decision made elsewhere.

Surcharge, service charge or tip: which is it?

These terms mean different things, and that is where much of the confusion begins. An operating-cost surcharge does not, by itself, tell customers what their server receives. The word “service” is not enough to establish whether a tip is still expected either. Before deciding what to leave, diners need to understand the restaurant’s policy: what does the charge fund, who receives the money, and what is left for the customer to decide at payment?

The IRS distinguishes voluntary tips from mandatory service charges for federal tax purposes. When the latter are distributed to employees, they are treated as wages rather than tips. That does not give us a set of instructions for every American restaurant. The distinction is useful nonetheless: two amounts that look similar on a check may have different legal treatment and different consequences for the person receiving them.

Advising travelers to deduct every surcharge from the tip would therefore be a mistake. Depending on the restaurant’s policy, that could penalize an employee without changing the money retained by the business to cover its costs. It is better to ask a straightforward question, without accusing anyone: does this charge take the place of a tip? How does the restaurant describe it to customers? Staff should be able to answer clearly, without leaving diners to guess where their money is going.

Interior of Billy Goat Tavern in Chicago, photographed in 2018
Historical illustration: Billy Goat Tavern, Chicago, 2018 — Ken Lund, via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 2.0. Image resized under the same license. This is an illustration, not evidence of the restaurant’s surcharge policy.

A restaurant can absolutely offer an appealing service-included model. For some diners, not having to calculate a tip at the end will be a real advantage. But the same information needs to appear when booking, on the menu and on the check. If the payment terminal then suggests adding something, it must be unmistakably optional. A poorly presented tip prompt can be enough to raise doubts again when everything had seemed clear.

The itemized bill is not the problem in itself. The problem is the gap between the wording used and what customers can understand from it. Saying that a charge “supports the team” may be accurate, but it needs an explanation. Does it cover wages, benefits, overhead or a combination of costs? Diners should not have to investigate the purpose of an amount automatically added to their bill.

We have already discussed tipping culture in the United States on TravelGuys. Surcharges complicate the issue further without replacing existing customs. Asking for clear prices does not mean asking Americans to abandon their habits. It does mean asking businesses to explain them. Visitors can respect a local custom if they know what belongs to that custom, what is already included and what the restaurant has chosen to add for its own purposes.

Explain your costs, certainly. But why leave them out of the price?

The strongest argument for an itemized surcharge deserves consideration: it may draw attention to a cost customers do not know about or underestimate. An owner who wants to fund better benefits or distribute pay more fairly can legitimately want to explain that decision. We have no objection to the ambition; quite the opposite. Food and service quality also depend on the team’s working conditions. Customers can reasonably take an interest in that aspect of what they are paying for.

Explaining where money goes still does not require leaving it out of the displayed price. In a hypothetical example, a $52 fixed-price meal can come with an explanation that part of the price helps fund the team. There is no need to display $50 and then add 4% to convey the same message. The explanation is worthwhile. Charging separately is an additional choice, requiring a justification beyond the desire to show customers where their money goes.

Another fair objection is how to compete with neighboring restaurants that also display incomplete prices. The first business to include its fees may look more expensive on a menu scanned in a hurry. That is a real commercial difficulty. But accepting it as inevitable means competing on how prices are displayed rather than on the meals themselves. If everyone keeps an attractive headline figure and adds their own line, diners have to do more calculations and ask more questions. Comparisons become harder for everyone.

An owner could instead make simplicity a selling point: dish prices that include the restaurant’s costs, a few clear words about service and taxes stated according to the applicable rules. Nothing revolutionary. Just the chance to understand the budget without opening several pages or questioning the staff. Not everyone chooses the lowest price. Knowing what to expect and being able to enjoy dinner without worrying about the check can be reasons to book too.

These fees also need to be distinguished from a genuine optional extra. Paying more for a more expensive ingredient or a different service is perfectly reasonable when the choice is explicit. Diners know what they are adding to the meal and what it costs. Our criticism concerns overhead charged separately from an ordinary meal, particularly when added automatically. Treating the two practices as identical would prevent a serious discussion of the problem and fail to recognize extras that offer real value.

Nobody is demanding an unchanging menu, or the same price for every dish and occasion. A restaurant’s offering should change with the seasons, ingredients and type of meal. Our request is much simpler: the price of the meal on offer should be clear without customers having to calculate it themselves. An exception can be explained. But when every bill comes with an exception, perhaps the advertised price needs to change instead of asking customers for more patience.

A disclosure in the terms does not solve everything

Billy Goat Tavern menu board photographed in November 2025; historical prices
Historical illustration: Billy Goat Tavern menu, 2025 — Spatms, via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0. Image resized under the same license. This is an illustration, not evidence of the restaurant’s surcharge policy.

This discussion extends well beyond restaurants. The FTC’s FAQ on its rule effective May 12, 2025 covers, among other things, live-event tickets and short-term lodging. We should not claim more for it than it says: the rule is not a blanket federal ban on every restaurant surcharge in the United States. Its scope is specific. Local rules and the circumstances of each transaction need separate examination; our criticism of the commercial practice does not replace that legal assessment.

For the lodging and ticketing covered, the FTC addresses, among other matters, automatically added fees described as optional because customers can challenge them. The parallel is useful when considering the customer’s experience. We are not using it to conclude that Boka or Beatrix are breaking this rule. Comparing two ways of charging does not extend a law to a different industry. That distinction matters, including in an opinion article.

Travelers are familiar with prices that change between searching and paying. Just yesterday, we looked at what hotel guests actually receive in return for their money. At a restaurant too, the different stages should be consistent. A brand can polish its website, reservation process and welcome, yet undermine some of that effort if the check introduces avoidable confusion. The final interaction with the customer deserves as much attention as the first.

An itemized check and a total price announced at the outset are entirely compatible. The itemization lets diners check what they consumed; the total lets them choose a restaurant and a meal. We need both, at different times. Nothing prevents a business from explaining its expenses while first giving customers the number relevant to their decision. Educating diners about costs should not become a reason to complicate the most basic information of all: how much it will cost.

Nor is it enough to state somewhere that a surcharge exists. A note buried in the terms, a small line at the bottom of a menu and an immediately visible price are not equally easy to spot. We have not studied how customers read the websites mentioned and do not claim to measure the effectiveness of their disclosures. Our expectation is more practical: people should understand the cost of a meal without having to search for a qualification or exception.

Restaurants would benefit from treating this as a service issue, beyond compliance alone. A simple test would be to ask customers how much they think they will pay and compare the answers with the expected check. If differences recur, the presentation needs attention. No elaborate technology is needed to start. The important step is listening to what customers actually understood rather than relying on what the restaurant believes it explained.

A few checks before booking

Until practices improve, check the current menu and any service-charge or surcharge conditions before reserving. The restaurant’s official website and the confirmation received are the first places to look, remembering that documents can change. A photo of an old menu or a listing on a platform does not guarantee today’s terms. For an important occasion, ask for a precise confirmation before choosing. A small effort beforehand can avoid a much less pleasant conversation at the end of the meal.

Think in terms of the whole meal budget: what does the meal you plan to order include, which drinks remain to be added, and what fees will still be charged? Depending on the restaurant, taxes, service, voluntary tips and extras need to be distinguished. We are not offering a supposedly universal percentage. The aim is to establish, in a few lines, what is certain and what still depends on the order. Then two restaurants can be compared on more than the first price highlighted on their websites.

For a business dinner, settle these questions before arriving. That avoids discussing the check in front of guests and lets travelers check any expense limit. A restaurant that is more expensive than expected can still be worth the money if the meal justifies it. But that decision should be possible when booking. Once dinner is over, it is rather late to tell customers they should have budgeted more or chosen somewhere else.

Entrance to Harry Caray’s in the Navy Pier pavilion in Chicago, photographed in 2013
Historical illustration: Entrance to Harry Caray’s at Navy Pier, Chicago, 2013 — Ken Lund, via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 2.0. Image resized under the same license. This is an illustration, not evidence of the restaurant’s surcharge policy.

With family or friends, price is obviously not the only consideration. Hours, dietary requirements, accessibility, how well the restaurant accommodates children and available time may matter more when choosing a restaurant. Knowing the price does not answer any of those questions. It simply makes the choice easier. Once the budget is understood, diners can focus on whether the place suits the evening they want, instead of spending their energy working out what lies behind the advertised amount.

If a line remains unclear when paying, ask what it means before deciding on a tip. There is no reason to be aggressive. The server may not have chosen the policy and may have to answer the same question all evening. A precise question will be more useful than a general complaint about American habits. It also avoids making the wrong person bear the consequences of an assumption about where the money goes.

And nothing obliges us to return on the next trip. This is not a call to boycott Chicago or a restaurant group over one policy. It is simply a reminder that clarity is part of what we buy, alongside food and service. Between two appealing places, the one that states its terms openly already has an advantage. At least we know the basis of our choice and can get on with enjoying the meal.

The same terms from reservation to payment

Reservation platforms and payment systems have a part to play too. We are not accusing any particular tool of a practice we have not verified. But essential information should not get lost between channels. If a restaurant explains its fees on its own website, customers booking elsewhere should be able to see those terms before confirming. A correct explanation on one channel does not inform everyone who arrived by a different route.

This matters particularly on mobile. When traveling, we often choose a restaurant on a phone between activities. Opening a long terms page, downloading a menu and matching it all against an abbreviated confirmation quickly becomes tedious. A few simple words beside the price would be more helpful. Nobody is asking a restaurant to simplify its cooking or give up its personality. We are asking it to make booking as easy to understand as the meal is supposed to be enjoyable.

The payment terminal should not introduce one last doubt. If service is included, say so before suggesting an extra tip. If it is not, customers should be able to understand that too, without asking an awkward question. We have no objection to suggestions in themselves. They should simply match what was announced for that meal. Uncertainty when taking out a card should never be what leads customers to pay again for something they thought they had already covered.

For the business, a practical check would already help: compare the menu, booking terms, confirmation sent and a sample check. Is the same wording used everywhere? Does the surcharge apply to the same amounts? Do teams know how to honor the promised removal? Have changes been reflected in every document? Those checks spare staff from inventing a fresh explanation at each table and customers from receiving several answers to the same question.

It would be equally misleading to look only at how often removal is requested. Few complaints do not prove that the policy is popular. Some diners may not notice it; others may accept it; others may prefer not to argue. Without asking them, we cannot know what explains their silence. A restaurant that wants to understand the reaction should ask how customers perceived the prices and fees. Saying nothing when paying does not necessarily mean approving everything on the bill.

Counter and dining room at Eleven City Diner in Chicago, 2017
Historical illustration: Eleven City Diner, Chicago, 2017 — Adam Jones, via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 2.0. Image resized under the same license. This is an illustration, not evidence of the restaurant’s surcharge policy.

This may seem secondary compared with hiring, purchasing or supply problems. It will obviously not solve any of those difficulties on its own. But it concerns the relationship that sustains a restaurant: customers know what they are buying, accept the price and want to return. Digital tools should help them reach that decision. Speeding up payment is not enough if it merely makes them pay faster for a check they have not had time to understand.

Conclusion: show the real price and spare us the negotiation

Restaurants need customers willing to pay a fair price for ingredients, work and service. They also need those customers’ trust. The two belong together. A clearly stated total will not make every restaurant affordable to everyone, but that is not its purpose. It lets diners see whether the meal fits their budget and whether they want to spend that amount on the experience offered. That is the basis of an honest choice.

Boka and Beatrix have chosen to add fees customers can ask to have removed. It is that method, set out in their own terms, that we dispute. We are not passing judgment on cooking we have not assessed for this article. Our preference is simply for the owner who openly states the price being asked. That seems more respectful than leaving diners to discover which part of the bill they can refuse and then find the words to do so in front of their guests.

A good restaurant can be expensive, and that is not a criticism in itself. Conversely, a few dollars added without being properly understood can be enough to spoil the memory of dinner. The issue is therefore also about consideration for the customer. Good hospitality does not end with the last course. It includes how the bill is presented and how they leave. Forgetting that at the precise moment they take out their card is a pity.

The debate revived this week deserves better than a caricature of greedy owners facing stingy customers. Both have pressures, and denying them helps nobody. But the restaurant remains responsible for how it displays its prices. If the meal costs $104, show $104. Customers will decide. They should not have to negotiate to find out the price of dinner. That is an elementary request, entirely compatible with quality restaurants being paid properly for what they do.

Sources and references

Axios — Chicago restaurant surcharges — October 28, 2026

Boka Restaurant Group — About Our Surcharge — accessed October 29, 2026; no publication date

Lettuce Entertain You — Beatrix surcharge disclosure — accessed October 29, 2026; no publication date

National Restaurant Association — Menu Prices — October 14, 2026

Illinois Restaurant Association — 2026 Chicago Restaurant Survey — survey conducted March 9–16, 2026; page accessed October 29, 2026

ABC7 Chicago — Restaurant surcharge investigation — November 20, 2024; historical reference

Internal Revenue Service — Tip recordkeeping and reporting — accessed October 29, 2026

Federal Trade Commission — Rule on Unfair or Deceptive Fees — FAQ — May 2025; accessed October 29, 2026

Olivier Delestre-Levai
Olivier Delestre-Levai
Olivier has been into airline blogging since 2010. First a major contributor to the FlyerTalk forum, he created the FlyerPlan website in July 2012, and writes articles with a major echo among airline specialists. He now co-runs the TravelGuys blog with Bertrand, focusing on travel experience and loyalty programs.
1,324FansLike
954FollowersFollow
1,272FollowersFollow
370SubscribersSubscribe

Trending posts

Recent posts

Bacchanal: a welcome renovation, but booking needs to be clearer

Caesars Palace will renovate its flagship buffet in 2027. We welcome the decision. But guests booking today should already be able to find the price of their dinner more easily and understand what their chosen time guarantees.

Hyatt and Delta: a partnership with uneven benefits

The Hyatt–Delta partnership is now up and running. Medallion members gain a new hotel benefit. For Hyatt loyalists, Delta’s ticket restrictions and the choice of airline program make the deal less appealing, especially for those who use Flying Blue.

Expedia cyberattack: the risk goes beyond payment details

Expedia has confirmed an intrusion through a vendor, but its scope remains unclear. Even without card numbers, booking details can make a scam convincing. Our view on protecting travel accounts.

FAA outage: the cost of a fragile air traffic control system

US airlines spent the weekend rebuilding their schedules after the November 13 outage. We look at which flights they prioritized, the rebooking options and the refund rights available to passengers.