Skip to content
A considered view of the world.
TravelGuys

Would you benefit from joining a hotel or airline loyalty program?

We often mention our membership of loyalty programs in our articles, and we receive many questions from our readers about the benefits of joining such programs in the airline and hotel industries.

Believing that they do not travel enough or wanting to have the freedom to choose without being “married” to a chain or an airline, many question the usefulness of such membership.

In fact, the topic of loyalty programs raises two distinct questions:

  • Are the benefits worth it?
  • Is the race for status worth it?

Are the benefits of loyalty programs worth it?

So what’s the point of being loyal to a hotel chain or airline, which restricts choice, if in the end you don’t get much out of it? It’s a legitimate question that deserves to be asked.

Here, it’s important to distinguish between the hotel and airline sectors.

In the hotel industry, simply being a member means at least 5 to 10% lower rates than public rates and online travel agencies. Among the appreciated advantages are upgrades (more or less systematic), access to lounges, the possibility of early arrival or late departure, free access to the spa…

In air travel, you will find lounge access, priority queuing and priority treatment in the event of IRROPS (delays or cancellations), as well as an additional baggage allowance. Contrary to popular belief, airlines don’t generally offer automatic upgrades, unlike the hotel industry (except for certain airlines which offer upgrade “vouchers” to their customers with the highest status). In some hotel programs, upgrading may be a right (subject to availability). In air travel, depending on your status, you may just be given priority if the airline is forced to upgrade.

In both cases, however, the customer will earn points or miles that can be exchanged for flights or free nights (well, not so free, since they will have “paid” for them with their previous trips).

Worth it? Yes ! Especially since membership is free. That’s the good news. The bad news, as you’d expect, is that the most attractive of these benefits are reserved for the most loyal of loyal customers, i.e. those with the highest status.

However, it is important to distinguish between hotels and airlines. A “business” passenger who usually travels in business class will have, in the price of his ticket, almost all the advantages linked to a high status. Ironically, since these are the passengers who have the easiest access to said statuses, the loyalty program offers them what they have already paid for! But they’ll be happy to take advantage of it during their economy-class vacations.

However, even business travelers don’t book a suite when they travel, and this type of upgrade is widely appreciated. And here, too, they take advantage of it during their vacations, even abusing it (seeing whole families come to pig out in a lounge originally intended for solo travelers to avoid paying for the restaurant in the evening is quite irritating for “normal” customers who can’t find a place).

Is the race for status worth it?

Loyalty program members are divided into “tiers” according to their spending. Oh yes, if you haven’t figured it out yet, a loyalty program doesn’t reward loyalty (the fact of preferring a particular brand) but the fact of spending a lot on it. One often leads to the other, but this needs to be made clear.

So, depending on their “loyalty”, customers will be awarded a “status” (silver, gold, platinum…).

If your activities naturally lead you to travel a lot, it makes sense to put all your eggs in one basket for maximum benefits. Better one platinum status on one program than four silvers on four different programs.

But what about the others?

Let’s be honest, the only statuses that are really worthwhile are usually the top two of the 3 or 4 offered by each program. In air travel, count at least 3 long-haul business round-trips per year, and in hotels 50 nights per year.

If you only travel for leisure, you’ll have realized that it’s out of reach unless you can afford to travel a lot, often, far and not in economy! Depending on the program, the first tier may offer some interesting advantages for those who are used to not having them, but don’t expect miracles. In 2021, access to a status may be simple but don’t expect it to last.

Of course, there is a category of people who make “status hunting” a sport, optimize their trips accordingly, and jump at any opportunity promotional fare or “market fare” to accumulate miles and chase premium status, makes “milleage runs” over a weekend just to fly, whatever the destination as long as they earn miles for cheap. But this article isn’t aimed at the maximum 0.1% of travelers, and they don’t need advice anyway.

The question that may arise is for a person who finds himself 3 or 4 nights away from an interesting status just a few weeks before the end of his qualification period. You’ll have to decide on a case-by-case basis, but it may be worthwhile to treat yourself to one or two weekends to achieve this status, even if it means staying in a cheap hotel close to home.

But to put it simply, if you don’t feel capable of achieving the two “top tier” of a loyalty program, forget it!

French people unloved by loyalty programs

The question also arises because, unlike other countries, such as the United States or other European countries, the French don’t seem to be overly sensitive to loyalty programs in the travel industry. Why ?

  • The French travel less for work than the Americans, Germans or English, and not in the same travel classes. Look at the number of business seats in a Lufthansa and Air France medium-haul aircraft and you’ll see what I mean.
  • The French – and this is a consequence of the previous point – are not used to making decisions based on loyalty programs, but rather on price or what they “know”. For air travel it will be Air France or the lowest fare, for hotels it will be Accor or AirBnb.
  • Partnerships between loyalty programs and bankcards are much more widespread abroad, particularly in the United States. There, simply holding a particular card “boosts” your membership of a program. Here, apart from the Amex Air France to a slight extent (XP gain), there is nothing to get excited about.

Membership yes, but status not for all!

As the question was in two parts, so will be our answer.

Joining a loyalty program costs nothing and provides some automatic advantages over non-members! There’s no reason not to take the loyalty cards of the chains and airlines you use the most. Over time, you may even realize that we’re getting close to some interesting things, which will help you rationalize your travel policy. But at least you’ll be doing it for the right reasons.

On the other hand, if you don’t travel much on a budget (unless your employer or customers are paying for it), there’s little point in jumping on the bandwagon and betting everything on a single program. In other words, if you do 5 weekends in Europe and one long-haul flight per year in economy, forget it! We’d like to point out, however (but it’s not available to everyone…) that holding an American Express Platinum (the “real” one, not the “Air France” one) gives you advantages such as access to airport lounges and 2nd best status at Hilton, Radisson, Marriott, Hertz and others.

And remember that hotel loyalty programs are generally more generous than airline loyalty programs.

Image : Membership in a loyalty program by FGC via shutterstock

Bertrand Duperrin
Bertrand Duperrinhttp://www.duperrin.com
Compulsive traveler, present in the French #avgeek community since the late 2000s and passionate about (long) travel since his youth, Bertrand Duperrin co-founded Travel Guys with Olivier Delestre in March 2015.
1,324FansLike
954FollowersFollow
1,272FollowersFollow
370SubscribersSubscribe

Trending posts

Recent posts

Bacchanal: a welcome renovation, but booking needs to be clearer

Caesars Palace will renovate its flagship buffet in 2027. We welcome the decision. But guests booking today should already be able to find the price of their dinner more easily and understand what their chosen time guarantees.

Hyatt and Delta: a partnership with uneven benefits

The Hyatt–Delta partnership is now up and running. Medallion members gain a new hotel benefit. For Hyatt loyalists, Delta’s ticket restrictions and the choice of airline program make the deal less appealing, especially for those who use Flying Blue.

Expedia cyberattack: the risk goes beyond payment details

Expedia has confirmed an intrusion through a vendor, but its scope remains unclear. Even without card numbers, booking details can make a scam convincing. Our view on protecting travel accounts.

FAA outage: the cost of a fragile air traffic control system

US airlines spent the weekend rebuilding their schedules after the November 13 outage. We look at which flights they prioritized, the rebooking options and the refund rights available to passengers.